30 May 2015

The most dangerous Internal conflict in muslim brotherhood


The internal crisis which appeared 10 days ago
, and the presence 2 of leaderships of MB organization, and the dispute  and authorities Is retribution or to peaceful means of change.



* Definition of the members of the two teams:

1- Before February 2014 = the old office  \ They are currently out of Egypt


Mahmoud Ezzat:
Vice of "Mohammed Badie"
Deputy leader of the Muslim Brotherhood since 2009
He called by "Ironman"
Secretary General of the group for six years (2004-2010), and at the age of 71 years
Membership Guidance Bureau since 1981

Mahmoud Ghazlan:
Officially speaking of MB after January 2011
He was secretary-general of the group between 2000 and 2001
Member of the Guidance Bureau of the group since 1995

Abdul Rahman Al-Barr :
Grand Mufti of MB - proffesor at Azhar University, 52 years old.

Mahmoud Hussein:
General Secretary of MB during the isolation Morsi

2- After February 2014 = new Office \ They are currently living in Egypt 


After partial internal elections in February 2014, which established a committee to manage the crisis between the Brotherhood and the Egyptian authority, and the outcome was 65% of MB youth with this new office.

Mohamed Kamal Wahdan:
is the new Acting Brotherhood guide
Professor of ear, nose and throat at Assiut University
age : 60 years.
"he was arrested less than a week."

Ibrahim Hussein:
General Secretary of the Freedom and Justice Party - 56-year-old.

Mohamed Montasser :
Official Media Speaker

The beginning of the problem:


  • After an absence of nearly 20 months from the scene,  the official spokesman of the Muslim Brotherhood  Mahmoud Ghozlan  "old office" wrote an article in 22 May and published in informal MB website entitled "Our call is remains and our revolution is continuous " which stated.
         -Peaceful and non-violence is our way
 -        Refusal to atone Muslims

The response of the youth group is very indignant and considered of abandonment and warned that this be a prelude to reconciliation with the regime.

  • sudden appearance of a long statement signed by 150 advocate and Islamic scholars, titled by "statement of Egypt" 27 May which stated:

- To have legitimate right to resist the injustice and retribution
- Stressed that the isolated President Mohamed Morsi is the legitimate president of the country

  • The spokesman of new team, "Mohd. Montasser" approve those preachers and scholars and supported them by facebook post.


  • Mahmoud Hussein the general Secretary "old team" worte a fb post that "Mamoud Ezzat" is the one who acting as acting leader based on MB internal rules. so this way  Rejecting the option of escalation that appeared in the long statement which signed by 150 advocate.


The new Guidance Office replied that as soon as he left Egypt = he lost his MB job.

------------

The real cause of the conflict:

  •  There are always different visions between MB members who are in Egypt and those who are abroad, and between the members inside and outside of prisons, and the international organization which takes into account regional considerations and internal organization.
  • Therefore real cause of the dispute is the desire of both teams in the control of the leadership of the group, not the dispute over the use of violent or peaceful ways to facing the coup.

 the new team knows well that they cannot use MB as a military group or to make an open war against the government.

  • The old team argues that the "Committee crisis," is just a committee, so they can freeze it after failing to achieve the objectives which it was created, and after 1year from this committee nothing happened to the coup.

 The old team cannot let the new team to use violence or even the threat of it, they are dealing with foreign countries and parliaments, which does not fit with the tone of violence

  • The new generations of MB wrote a Hashtag called : we wont going back. which means that they wont going back to the old leaders who cannot defend the presidency of Mursi.


---------------

Strange paradoxes:


  • The clashes appeared at the same time the emergence of the intensification of the conflict between al-Sisi VS Mubarak regime.
  • The leaders and members of the Muslim Brotherhood still want revenge from el.sisi at the same time of their Minister of Planning and International Cooperation at the time of Morsi = Amr Darrag = Party responsible for External Relations that Sisi has refused to break up the MB  demonstration by force and the force was approved by majority of government!

  • The Old team are followers of Sayyid Qutb = supported and favored hostile rhetoric\ extremist  in the demonstrations of MB = at the same time they agree with establish a private organization = Create a secret military device to fight against those who stand agaisnt MB from the government \ police \ military.!
  • So they left militants speaking in a Rab3a field to bring more sympathy by using the name of religionHowever they surprised how young Muslim Brotherhood supporters turned to violence !!
  • Naming Egyptian military by "occupier"  is so weird,even Imam Hassan al-Banna did not called the army like that when the army was cooperating with England.
  • The irony here is those signatories to the statement "150 scholars" those who ask their society to be calm and handle the probs with their own govern. but in Egypt case they ask them to FIGHT !!
  • They also did not write anything about: the Houthis in Yemen \\ Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Shiites in Iraq \\ Nusayris in Syria  \\ clashes in Libya \\ clashes in  Somalia \\ Palestine  issues \\ MB who support the Shiites\US new Parliament  in Iraq \\ repeated bombings \\ any advices to Muslim teams competing on the land of Syria \\ or even anything against ISIS !!

No comments:

Post a Comment